Are Fragrance Oils And Essential Oils The Same?

If you’re diving into the world of candles, wax melts, soaps, or skincare, you've likely asked: Are fragrance oils and essential oils the same?

It’s a common question - especially as more people become conscious of the ingredients in the products they buy or make. Scent is a major selling point in home fragrance and body care, so understanding the difference between natural plant extracts and manufactured scent blends is essential.

Though both types of oil are used to make products smell amazing, they’re not interchangeable. They differ in how they’re made, how they perform, their benefits, and even their environmental impact.

What Are Essential Oils?

Essential oils are highly concentrated plant extracts obtained through steam distillation or cold pressing. These natural oils capture the aroma and therapeutic properties of the source plant, such as lavender, peppermint, eucalyptus, or tea tree.

They’re widely used in aromatherapy, skincare, wellness routines, and natural living.

Popular examples include:

• Lavender – known for its calming, sleep-inducing qualities

• Peppermint – fresh and cooling; often used for focus and headache relief

• Tea Tree – antibacterial and purifying

• Eucalyptus – invigorating, helps with congestion

Because they are volatile (meaning they evaporate quickly), essential oils often produce lighter, more delicate aromas that fade faster than synthetic alternatives.

What Are Fragrance Oils?

Unlike their natural counterparts, these oils are typically created in a lab. They may be entirely synthetic, derived from natural sources, or a combination of both. Their purpose is simple: to smell amazing and perform well in a variety of products.

There are three common types:

• Synthetic – made from man-made aroma compounds

• Natural isolates – separated scent molecules from natural sources

• Nature-identical – lab-replicated versions of real plant molecules
  
  

These scent blends are often found in:

• Candles and wax melts

• Perfumes and body sprays

• Lotions, soaps, and cosmetics

• Room sprays and diffusers

• Household cleaners
  
  

Because they're designed for performance, they tend to last longer, have a stronger scent throw, and offer a more stable result - particularly when heat is involved, as in candle-making.

Are Fragrance Oils and Essential Oils the Same?

Short answer: No, they are not.

Even though both are used to make products smell good, they differ in nearly every other way—from their origin and processing to their cost, shelf life, and safety.

Here’s a side-by-side breakdown:

Pros and Cons of Each

Essential Oils – Advantages

• 100% natural

• Offer therapeutic and wellness benefits

• Appeal to eco-conscious consumers

• Suitable for aromatherapy and holistic skincare
  
  

Essential Oils – Drawbacks

• More costly to produce

• Limited scent range

• Some can be unstable in heat or light

• May not be ideal for all candle or soap bases

Synthetically Crafted Oils – Advantages

• Huge range of scents (even fantasy or food-inspired blends)

• Longer-lasting aroma

• Great performance in products like candles and wax melts

• Affordable and consistent batch to batch
  
  

Drawbacks

• No therapeutic properties

• May include synthetic allergens

• Not suitable for all-natural product lines

When Should You Use Each Type?

It depends on what you’re creating and who your target customer is.

Use essential oils if:

• You’re making aromatherapy or wellness items

• Your brand values natural and organic ingredients

• You’re formulating roll-ons, skincare, or massage products

• You want to emphasize therapeutic benefits

Use scented blends if:

• You need a strong scent throw in candles or wax melts

• You want a wide variety of scent choices

• You're looking for consistency in large-scale production

• You’re creating perfumes, soaps, or home fragrance items

Many makers use a mix of both. For example, you might blend lavender essential oil with a soft musk-based scent blend to add depth and longevity to a candle or body butter.

Are These Oils Safe to Use?

There's a lot of misinformation out there. Some assume lab-made oils are toxic, but that’s not necessarily true.

When purchased from reputable suppliers, these ingredients are IFRA-compliant, meaning they meet international safety standards for use in cosmetics and home products. Just like with essential oils, misuse - like applying undiluted oil directly to the skin—can cause irritation.

Tips for safe usage:

• Always follow recommended dilution rates

• Patch test skin products before use

• Never use undiluted oils directly on skin

• Store all oils in a cool, dark place

Whether you’re using a botanical extract or a synthetic blend, safety starts with sourcing and responsible formulation.

Blending Both Worlds

Some crafters find great success blending both types of oil. This allows for a fuller, more complex fragrance while maintaining some natural elements.

Examples include:

• Enhancing citrus oils with stabilizing scent molecules to extend shelf life

• Layering herbal or floral notes for a deeper, longer-lasting perfume

• Adding natural essential oils to give a synthetic blend a botanical boost

This hybrid approach is especially helpful when you want a natural identity without sacrificing performance.

Final Thoughts: Are Fragrance Oils and Essential Oils the Same?

To circle back: Are fragrance oils and essential oils the same? No - though they’re both used for scenting products, they’re fundamentally different in how they’re made and how they function.

Natural plant oils offer wellness benefits and appeal to those seeking a holistic lifestyle. Synthetically created oils provide strong, long-lasting scent and greater versatility, especially for home fragrance and soap-making.

Knowing when to use each one (or both) can help you create better, safer, and more appealing products - whether you're crafting for personal use or selling to customers.

Shop Premium Oils with Confidence

At House of Scent, we offer a carefully curated selection of undiluted, high-performance oils designed for makers, hobbyists, and indie brands. Whether you're looking for classic aromas, trend-led blends, or something totally unique, our range has everything you need to bring your creations to life.

Explore our range today and start crafting with confidence.

SHOP ALL FRAGRANCE OILS